Commentary by James Shott
The Republican Party is a mess. It has:
• Lost its way as a political force;
• Largely abandoned American traditions and founding principles;
• Become “Democrat lite,” because Republicans nowadays so often think and vote like Democrats;
• Failed to listen to its members.
the GOP disintegrating there is little to halt or slow the devolution
of the United States into just one more failed socialist state,
something Barack Obama has worked tirelessly to achieve, and which
either Hillary Clinton or Bernie Sanders would continue.
Trump leads conventional Republican candidates in the primaries and
caucuses, which surprises and confounds the party elite, who thought he
would be a flash in the pan, and would soon fade away, leaving them to
continue abandoning their party’s role in protecting the American way of
life, and ignoring the concerns of their voters. This effectively
demonstrates how badly they have misjudged the level of anger and
disgust with the current state of their party that rank and file
Republicans feel today, as well as the high degree of dissatisfaction
they and a host of non-Republicans have with the federal government.
behavior is at once energizing and destructive. It has won him a large
following, and at the same time has exaggerated the party’s fracturing,
pitting candidates against him and against each other in an elementary
schoolyard brawl. But his tactic of saying things others are afraid to
say, and ignoring the stupid but daunting rules of political
correctness, has energized millions of dissatisfied Republicans, and has
attracted non-Republicans, including blacks and Hispanics, to his
The “establishment” Republicans – those whose
weak-kneed perspective has transformed the party to Democrat lite – are
working to subvert the primary process, disenfranchising the Republican
primary/caucus voters. The establishment’s behavior over recent years
is precisely why things are as they are, and hardly anything could be
worse than ignoring the plain message sent by the voters in the
primaries and caucuses that substantial change in the GOP is needed. It
is difficult to imagine that the Republican Party will be able to
survive if it betrays the loud voices of those who make up the party
telling them to man up, and still remain a viable political entity.
perfect example of the tone-deafness of the party elite is the
blistering condemnation of Donald Trump by 2012 GOP presidential
candidate Mitt Romney, who turned backflips to make Trump seem like the
Devil incarnate. If that doesn’t seem strange, consider that during the
campaign four years ago, following Trump’s endorsement, Romney
effusively praised him, and then proceeded to lose the election by
failing to be as strong in his opposition to Obama as he was in his
praise of Trump.
It is another tribute to the failure
of the GOP establishment that it regards Romney’s foolish trashing of
Trump more highly than the candidate now leading the party’s nominating
Peggy Noonan, who was Special Assistant to President Ronald Reagan and now a political columnist for The Wall Street Journal,
wrote last week, “I think we are seeing a great political party shatter
before our eyes. I’m not sure I see a way around or through.” Of the
spectacle of last Tuesday’s debate in Detroit she noted that the current
GOP crisis is “something bigger than 1976, that traumatic year when a
Republican insurgent almost toppled the incumbent Republican president.
Bigger too than 1964, when Goldwater conservatism swept the primaries
and convention and lost the country.”
She asserts that
what is happening now is more serious and less reparable because it is
not about political philosophy. But it seems that the party’s
abandonment of conservative principles is precisely what this is about.
ignoring the increasing frustration of the rank and file over
Republicans in Congress failing to stand up against liberalizing of
government policies and recent executive branch excesses, the party
elite set the stage for Donald Trump’s stunning dominance among those
seeking the party’s nomination.
Where Trump is
concerned the party elite is damned if they do and damned if they don’t.
If they allow the process to play out and he wins the nomination,
someone believed by millions to be neither a Republican, a conservative
or suitable to be president will carry the Party banner into the
If they continue the plot to subversively
prevent Trump from getting the nomination, they will alienate millions
of otherwise dependable Republican voters.
likely at this stage that the Republican Party will endure, but not as a
meaningful political force equal to the Democrat Party. The Republican
establishment will be left holding the tatters of a once-Grand Old Party
while conservatives move on to greener pastures.
Republican voters and others dissatisfied with the status quo that
might have stuck with or joined a conservative GOP now will seek an
organization that honors and defends the U.S. Constitution not only in
word, but also in deed.
The question is whether without
a viable opponent to Hillary or Bernie, or a split among those
opponents, will it be possible four or eight years later to repair the
damage likely to result from another liberal/socialist in the White
Cross-posted from Observations