The Michael Medved Show blog yesterday, “Simplistic Silliness on Immigration Courtesy of “Grandma,” is the typical Bush Republican mantra which amounts to what one commenter said – it’s pure “BOVINE EXCREMENT!!!”
Here are few excerpts:
“Isn’t it possible that “closing the borders” isn’t just inconvenient – but virtually impossible? . . .
“Could we really shut out all immigrants (including the more than half-a-million who enter legally each year) and block all visitors too? Does any sane individual believe that sealing off the United States from all foreigners for some period of time would help our economy or our country? Would we also make it impossible for, say, the Japanese managers and automotive engineers from Honda and Toyota to enter the country to help supervise the new production plants that employ tens of thousands of Americans? . . .
“The reason that mainstream conservatives insist on comprehensive immigration reform rather than simplistic sloganeering is their recognition of government’s limited ability to control human behavior. . .
“Meanwhile, on our side of the aisle discussion of elegantly, instantly, effortlessly “closing the border” or wondering “why we don’t stop illegal immigration, now” isn’t helpful, and amounts to childish wishful thinking. . ."
Ok, there you go Michael – hummmm… I don’t recall any sane person suggesting that we seal off the US from all foreigners – especially the “Japanese managers and automotive engineers from Honda and Toyota”! Give us a break, what kind of a nit wit are you? Or more to the point, what kind of childish and simplistic “wishful thinkers” do you thing we are?
The only limitation the US has to controlling illegal human behavior is one thing – the will to end ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION NOW! The great majority of American citizens have the will, but not our elected officials.
Let’s get to your real agenda of what you call the “mainstream conservatives.” First let me correct you. Michael, you don’t represent the mainstream. We are the mainstream conservatives and the elitist Bush Republicans, like you, have quite forgotten us. All your blather is nothing more than an attempt to cloak a globalist free trade agenda that relies on a continued supply of cheap illegal labor.
The “free trade” Bush Republicans as well as the “adopt an illegal” leftist Democrats will find out in 2008, that the collective will of the mainstream American people will not be ignored. Nothing is impossible – especially if the life of this great nation depends upon stemming the tide of ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION!!!
Illegal Immigration is a huge problem and you are right, something MUST be done! We need to continue to stay on top of our elected officials and let them hear the voice of the people on this issue..and not let up!!
ReplyDeleteI read Medved's blog from the link you provided! Looks like MOST of the commenters on his blog disagreed with him also! The ONE thing he did say that made sense is that immigrants that are here LEGALLY need to be closely monitored AND kept up with! I do agree with that...so many times Visa's expire and the government doesn't have a clue or doesn't care, not sure which!!
Unfortunately, I see this problem getting worse with the libs that will now be in control of the House and Senate!!
Amen!...this country is dying from within not without its borders!!..Seal the GATES!
ReplyDeleteThanks for commenting on my blog. I write a post or two on immigration just about every week. I've got a real comprehensive critique from last summer called "Basic Division: The GOP and Immigration Reform" if you'd like to search it on my blog. Medved offers no credible critque of Noonan's argument. One can debate the numbers all one wants, but if you live in So Cal like I do, you'll know that the number one problem is Latino aliens who are not assimilating. Now, don't get me started about all the Asians who speak Chinese (or what not) when I'm shopping for my dinner groceries at Ralph's here in Irvine. We need to clamp down on all the B1-B's who are bringing over every aunt and uncle under heaven from the home country. But first thing's first -- no "Hispanic Nation." Start with that, then we'll get to all the visa breakers and what not. Geez, just think, I'm actually pro-immigration -- I see diversity as powerfully strengthening our country. I'm just tired of all this lawbreaking, as you can see from my posts. Come back over from time to time, leave a comment, and I'll do the same.
ReplyDeleteP.S. I like your blog, but if you're interested, I know some quick tips that you might really like (switching to Haloscan comments for one).
Burkean Reflections
Yes to Haloscan!
ReplyDeleteThanks for adding us to your blogroll, your kindness has been reciprocated.
Medved is particularly strange on this issue. I've caught him referring to illegal immigrants as "Americans" on three or four occassions. Such as "are we really going to start deporting Americans?"
It's conflation run amok!
All the best,
Jake